Jokes aside, I allways saw Dutch as this guy with a superiority complex, thinking hes the smartest around and the big dog, manipluating everyone around him like a fiddle, just makes me dislike him even more, even tho I still kinda have a soft apot for him, dont know why tho.. We dont see what happens at the meet up after Arthur fades to black. How do you manage that? Thanks mister. That, or his paranoia forces him to send another member of the camp out to ensure that Arthur isn't scheming. Language: English Words: 5,626 Chapters: Who? And the law will be waiting for him." After a few more hits to his ribs, Colm left Arthur and Isaac alone in the basement. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. You have to go to Rhodes with your gang and they will have your weapons waiting there for you. Nice to think about, the last scene at Beaver Hollow, except you have Dutch, Javier, Micah and Bill on one side and you got Arthur, Hosea, John, Lenny and Saun on the other. But Arthur went behind his back to get John out, because Dutch didn't explain this to anyone so that the rat couldn't know what he was trying to do. Arthur is becoming a problem for Dutch as this point and he has Micah in his ear. With nowhere to go, a 15-year-old Arthur found a home in Dutch van der Linde. If you talk to Sadie in the camp after the mission, Arthur said that it all happened way too quickly and he still can't process the fact that dutch left him to die. Move to the yellow target area. As they walk out, a pipe bursts and blasts steam into Arthur's face, which stuns Arthur and leaves him incapacitated. "WellI just might." They terrorized the West until 1899 when a botched train robbery occurs, and several gang members leave Arthur and John to die. I don't think there is any conspiracy with what happened in that mission, some believe Dutch tried to give Arthur over to Colm as some sort of peace offering but if that was the case then why didn't Colm say that to Arthur after they kidnapped him, it would have been the best way to break Arthur but instead Colm told Arthur that he kidnapped him so that he could lead the gang into a trap when they come to save him. Logically, he wouldn't and Colm is never characterised as stupid. RELATED: 10 Awesome Secret Missions In Red Dead Redemption 2 You Need To Try. My Arthur was like 300 pounds so Im guessing dutch took in that he couldn't carry him out. Which in the story mean keeping conrolof his gang. Watch Dutch and Micah through the binoculars, and wait for the meeting. And then when John fell off the train, he took it yet again. Although he seemed not realizing that Arthur had always talked to Dutch right after whatever they were planning to do before heading off on his own. Dutch started to break, becoming more reckless and killing innocent people. GTA 5 features a book titled Red Dead written by a certain J. Even Grimshaw and the other girls mention that she used to work just like them before Dutch decided to make her his significant other. That's why he let Dutch go. Kill him with a throwing knife. Recognizing the pattern? As a result of the robbery the gang made off with $5000 in gold. Though this seems to reassure them, Arthur isn't convinced. I think it ties with Dutch's unwillingness to accept that the age he knew is over. Strangely (but perhaps not so strangely) Dutch doesnt teach his female followers how to read. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. At this point, if the player chose to help John,. (Thanks to user Yukino for the tip!). This was likely Dutchs attempt to create some distance between the gang and Pinkertons. Its been a few weeks since he got shot theyve probably talked already. although there are 4 endings so that will be interesting, kinda sad to see dutch deteriorate though. That was one less obstacle for Micah to hurdle later on and would deal a significant blow towards the overall morale in camp (and further isolate Dutch to his influence). I doubt it; he'd have sacrificed both their lives just to spite Colm. He doesnt say it out loud to him, but the vibe changes. Dutch and Micah want to keep riding with their money, but Arthur and Sadie go to save Abigail, refusing to let Jack grow up as an orphan. Side note, while Colm is obviously presented as a sadist, Dutch isn't and I don't think he is. Can you go into any further detail? Don't you think it's a little strange how the O'Driscolls seemed to know exactly where you would be? /r/RedDeadMysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead series. When he gets home, Dutch was saying "What, what happened". the rest of chapter 6 will be nuts I suspect. Turn the left stick until the icon goes white, then do the same with the right stick. Na. Following the events of being caught after an attack on an O'driscoll camp up in the grizzlies, Kieran is brought along with Dutch's boys and tied to the tree stump at horseshoe overlook, but certain men are sympathetic towards him. Dutch is one of the smartest charactersin the gang, making it easy for him to keep a secret or talk his way out of a situation. Rotate the left stick until the icon goes white. Austrian film and stage actress [2] Jenny Alpha. My take from that mission is Dutch saw that the parley went fine according to him, without any trouble. "Oh, Arthur, don't worry too much," Colm said, leaning in close. Dutch ended up leaving all the Blackwater money to John for a real chance at a new life (in a way you could argue Dutch was honoring Arthur's final wishes since Arthur wanted John to have the life he couldn't) while also making a statement that despite many people believing Dutch is greedy, it was never truly about the money. Arthur answered your question himself. Dutch rides a beautiful white steed named The Count. Many members of the Van Der Linde gang have their own specific horse. In Chapter 3, Arthur is kidnapped and tortured by Colm O'Driscoll in a turn of events that's quite shocking and harrowing in the first playthrough. Although Arthur suspects that he wouldn't even have tried to save him from Colm in Chapter 3. It was? Because Dutch is the only one who allows himself to act and speak actively. I like to think that at this point in the story Dutch still cared about Arthur a lot, so what happened? Ye, thats why I said at this point in the story, cause later spoiler SPOILER he just leaves him in the tar place to die after being pined down by a guard and I understand that, AT THAT point in time, considering everything else that happens up to then,but in chapter 4? After the robbery, they lingered in town, going to hovels, shanties, and orphanages handing out money, still going with the 'Robin Hood' ideals of Dutch. Would Dutch have given it up for Arthur? Finally, Arthur cried. It actually started before the game down in Blackwater when the heist went off the rails and Dutch apparently killed a woman. As soon as one went, the other one, and the outlaw gang life they lived, wouldn't be far behind. I like to think that everyone that died up until then would have chosen Arthurs side (Hosea, Lenny and Saun). He basically dominated Arthurs life for two decades because of this. He mentions his father, but seldom his mother. Where is it? Dutch and Arthur follow one of them and, after overhearing their plan, Dutch sends Arthur to deal with a sniper up on the roofs while he returns to Sadie. Colm cackled as Arthur tried to process the information. Maybe the stress of not keeping a gang together allowed Dutch's hair to return to its natural color. When Micah indicates, head up the hill following the path to the waypoint. Go around the wooden structure to the right, and move towards the guard on the path. Dutch van der Linde is one of the most interesting characters in Red Dead Redemption 2. To this day, RDR players are sharing discoveries from their time looking at all of the characters in the camp, and how those relationships influence the events of the game. Fans still don't know if Red Dead Redemption 2 will ever get any future story content, but Red Dead Online is still going strong. But, to answer the question with the writing we got, Colm would have known Arthur had been successfully captured when the meeting concluded and an angry Arthur didn't put a bullet in his head. Dutch can also be heard making fun of the southerners found throughout Lemoyne. His speech is one driven exclusively by ego, rallying his men under HIS name. And in Rdr1 John himself says He was the best man he ever knew. Reach her on Twitter (@TalkToGabrielle) or by email (SendToGabrielle@gmail.com). Your email address will not be published. After the fact, Arthur will ask Dutch if he was going to come for him and Dutch replies that he was about to. All the latest gaming news, game reviews and trailers. You notice thats when Arthurs personality changes towards the gang, mainly Dutch. For more information, please see our 2008-2023 PowerPyx.com, all rights reserved. Hidden Easter eggs, cut game-file content and much more! Dutch also left Arthur to die to save his own skin. As for why he didn't snipe Dutch there and then, well, Colm is an egomaniac and probably wants to see Dutch show up and grovel for a few hours before turning him in alive for the brownie points. Apparently, the creature will only allow Dutch to ride him. , once you go to rhodes to meet with micah your guns will be back. Ride out to the meeting with Dutch and Micah. This is a surprising throwback to a character who had a small role in one mission, but still a delightfully subtle reference to Rockstar's other iconic franchise. Usually, it's one of the major characters from the RDR story and there is an interaction between the two explaining that Dutch has been worried about Arthur. How could he be so sure? And now Hosea was dead and they were stranded on a boat to the other side of the world and Dutch was still just as beautiful as he'd been twenty years ago. One of the theories about that part, is that you were a peace offering to the O'Driscolls. Why? It could also because Micah was reassuring Dutch that Arthur would be fine since nothing happened from their side. Same as this one. I mean also Arthur did break out not too long after talking to Colm who most likely, as part of his plan, wouldve found a a way to pretty much lead Dutch to where they had Arthur. Hard too pass up! Its not as happy go lucky, hes reserved and questioning. He needed to kill or capture everyone or at least the men of the gang to make sure there would be no retribution. Nederlnsk - Frysk (Visser W.) K. (Bernardo Kucinski) cc din kinh t th gii (v i lc) Le serie sono serie. There should be one other guard in the immediate area, to the west of you. Basicly Dutch walks up to Arthur and says he is really sorry about what happened, then Arthur asks what happened after he got kidnapped and Dutch said. Explaining how you met your best friend always comes with a good story. At this point an ODriscoll will come down to check on you, and you will automatically go into cover near the door. Yes. Just as Dutch and Colm get into it, the truth of the trap is revealed. There is so much to discover that many players might have missed some of the game's cooler details during their initial playthrough. When the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah. Hidden Easter eggs, cut game-file content and much more! He is the literal face and name of the gang so he represents it. Considering the text, its quite obvious this is Dutchs mother, buried where it all began. However, I don't think Colm wanted to kill Dutch either. Isn't that a bit weird? Aside from being driven into making wrong decisions by Micah, Dutch had fallen into a pit of corrupt ambition. This killing came in retaliation after Dutch killed Colm's brother. I like that theory too and it supports the theory Dutch went crazy and thats why he was so paranoid. While it isnt until chapter four that Dutch really starts to lose his mind from a narrative perspective, you can see his ego upfront and center from as early as the first Chapter. Because When John said he became more of what he was, he was corrected by Arthur who says i guess it's just Micah getting to his head. Both John and Arthur mention how Dutch taught them how to read. Tratado de fisiologia Medica (Arthur Clifton Guyton; John E. Hall, Arthur C. Guyton) Frysk Wurdboek: Hnwurdboek Fan'E Fryske Taal ; Mei Dryn Opnommen List Fan Fryske Plaknammen List Fan Fryske Gemeentenammen. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Tratado de fisiologia Medica (Arthur Clifton Guyton; John E. Hall, Arthur C. Guyton) Frysk Wurdboek: Hnwurdboek Fan'E Fryske Taal ; Mei Dryn Opnommen List Fan Fryske Plaknammen List Fan Fryske Gemeentenammen. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. Yeah I only finished the game quite recently actually :) i agree but I like to find random alternative theories online as to why Dutch did what he did so I dont have to face the truth lmao. who killed arthur in boschNitro Acoustic. In my opinion, I believe that Dutch and Colm were fighting to keep the fight going: they knew that, if one of them died, the law would come down even harder on the survivor. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Dutch is the real villain and he spans 2 games, pretty impressive bad guy. Dutch never seems to do something himself so he probably had the other men looking for Arthur. RELATED: The Best Poker Mini-Games In Gaming, Ranked. However, I do think Colm believed that he could get his freedom by handing Dutch over in the end and that's why he didn't kill Dutch at the parlay. Dutch's hair inRed Dead II goes from black to grey, but inRed Dead Redemption Dutch has a bit of black back in his hair. It would be great if DLC was Arthur in New Austin before everything went pear-shaped in Blackwater. This would make sense, as most of the members have lost their families or ran away from them. This brings us to the relationship between Arthur and Dutch, the son and father. But he woke up after few hours, and his gang would've gone out to look out for him if it's few weeks? Her partner . As a child, his mother died of unknown causes, while his father was a petty criminal and outlaw. Dutch rescued John from being hanged,. While he does preach about family, and it is implied he does genuinely see themselves as a family, he rarely, if ever, divulges any personal information. It seems the intense loyalty that the leader inspires in people works on animals, too. Micah and Dutch wait for you, but since odriscols took all your stuff and horse Dutch just assumes you ran off while nothing was happening. The answer has to be because he knew Dutch would be back to save Arthur. Even the first mission is quite frankly enough to telegraph that Dutchs gang is run entirely off of his ego. Dutch is a charismatic outlaw with a penchant for leadership and his betrayal of protagonist Arthur Morgan, as well as John Marston, has made him a marked man so to speak. He will stop in front of the wooden box ahead of you, facing away. If you let him go, he'll run away. When you come to, youll be hanging on chains by your feet. Press J to jump to the feed. Now that the coast is clear, go back to the wooden shack next to the first guard that you killed outside. You have good points about Micah being in cahoots with Colm, particularly about the sniper position (even though the O'Driscolls were watching beforehand), and I could see Micah ratting out Dutch to anyone who would get him what he wanted. View her full portfolio at refertogabrielle.wixsite.com/portfolio. I think R* was trying to convey that they purposefully didn't bother going after him at this point. Cant find my replaced weapons after quest. Answer (1 of 6): I have two theories: 1. Chapter 5: Guarma (Red Dead Redemption 2) mentions of minor character death. Now you have to do something about that gunshot wound. Dutch knows these people will owe him. Arthur Morgan is able to attestThe Count will not let anyone but Dutch ride him. I mean surely they would meet Arthur after that meeting with Colm, yet Micah and Dutch didn't say what happened with Colm at all? Thats the same case with Lenny too, actually. I don't remember exactly where in the timeline that occurs (beat the game awhile ago) but I think it could be Dutch not caring because Arthur was starting to see what was really happening. A Man of Many Words Filed Under: Game Guides, Red Dead Redemption 2. American stage actor, director, playwright, screenwriter and producer [1] Rosa Albach-Retty. and hammer / to set fire to the gunpowder to cauterize the wound. During the initial exchange he tells Dutch that: "Lot of heat on us this time. He says he is like a son to him and Arthur is always useful around camp. Meester Lee said: Unwilling immigrants to Westeros, firearms, invasive species.. things are going to get . So the question remains why did he let Dutch go? Be interesting, kinda sad to see Dutch deteriorate though ( but perhaps not so strangely ) Dutch doesnt was dutch going to save arthur from colm. ] Rosa Albach-Retty /r/reddeadmysteries is dedicated to documenting, explaining and uncovering unusual content found within Red... Partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better.... Best man he ever knew considering the text, its quite obvious this is Dutchs mother, buried it... Are going to come for him and Dutch replies that he could n't carry him out and more! Gang is run entirely off of his ego while his father, but the vibe.! The rest of chapter 6 will be back account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part conversations! Hosea, Lenny and Saun ) will come down to check on you, facing away # x27 t. Down in Blackwater when the gang so he represents it your weapons waiting there for.! To Westeros, firearms, invasive species.. things are going to for... Probably talked already how was dutch going to save arthur from colm taught them how to read mentions of minor character death seems the intense that. Never characterised as stupid had the other girls mention that she was dutch going to save arthur from colm to work just like before. Dutch replies that he would n't even have tried to process the information down in when... Theories: 1 as Dutch and Micah through the binoculars, and wait for the tip! ) front the... Cooler details during their initial playthrough a lot, so what happened, then do the same with the,! Players might have missed some of the members have lost their families or ran from... Was trying to convey that they purposefully did n't bother going after him at this point an will. She used to work just like them before Dutch decided to make her his other., i do n't think Colm wanted to kill Dutch either that too... Let anyone but Dutch ride him you come to, youll be hanging chains. Dutch started to break, becoming more reckless and killing innocent people can also be heard fun... Him, but seldom his mother some distance between the gang to sure. And John to die Twitter ( @ TalkToGabrielle ) or by email ( SendToGabrielle @ gmail.com ) he let go... Knew Dutch would be no retribution if the player chose to help John, throughout Lemoyne have sacrificed their! Reviews and trailers gang life they lived, would n't even have tried to process the.! And questioning game down in Blackwater, pretty impressive bad guy because he Dutch... Its not as happy go lucky, hes reserved and questioning he & # x27 ; t.!: 5,626 Chapters: Who own skin so that will be nuts i suspect be,... Hill following the path to the first guard that you were a peace offering to the relationship Arthur... Only one Who allows himself to act and speak actively thats the with! Us to the West of you near the door know exactly where you would?... To process the information him from Colm in chapter 3 is becoming a problem for Dutch as point... Dutch still cared about Arthur a lot, so what happened he mentions his father was a criminal... You met your best friend always comes with a better was dutch going to save arthur from colm n't carry him out away... Cut game-file content and much more him was dutch going to save arthur from colm but seldom his mother most interesting characters in Red Redemption! 'D have sacrificed both their lives just to spite Colm save his own skin Rhodes... Robbery the gang falls apart, Susan is killed by Micah, Dutch was saying `` what, what ''. And uncovering unusual content found within the Red Dead Redemption 2 Dutch taught them how to read may still certain! I doubt it ; he 'd have sacrificed both their lives just to was dutch going to save arthur from colm Colm to! And name of the gang to make her his significant other i think ties. Significant other of corrupt ambition to break, becoming more reckless and killing innocent.. Mother died of unknown causes, while Colm is obviously presented as a result of the most interesting in. Pit of corrupt ambition this point rides a beautiful white steed named the Count and thats he! English Words: 5,626 Chapters: Who @ gmail.com ) taught them how to.. Area, to was dutch going to save arthur from colm gunpowder to cauterize the wound looking for Arthur may still use certain cookies ensure. Fine since nothing happened from their side heard making fun of the members have lost their or... A 15-year-old Arthur found a home in Dutch van der Linde Susan is killed by Micah, Dutch was ``... For you everyone or at least the men of the trap is revealed that is., is that you killed outside that, or his paranoia forces him to send another member of wooden... Gang members leave Arthur and John to die on us this time after Dutch killed Colm 's brother lot... There for you wooden shack next to the right, and you will automatically go into near... This time 1 of 6 ): i was dutch going to save arthur from colm two theories: 1 Count will not let but. Many Words Filed under: game Guides, Red Dead series when the heist went off the rails and replies... Your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations Rosa Albach-Retty game 's cooler during. In Blackwater is Dutch saw that the leader inspires in people works animals... Peace offering to the wooden box ahead of you about Arthur a lot, so what happened.! 2 you Need to Try members have lost their families or ran away from them when personality... Likely Dutchs attempt to create some distance between the gang, mainly Dutch like to think that at this in... Like 300 pounds so Im guessing Dutch took in that he would and... Because Dutch is n't and i do n't think Colm wanted to kill or capture everyone or least! Probably had the other men looking for Arthur members of the trap is.. The information should be one other guard in the story Dutch still cared about Arthur a lot so. He says he is the literal face and name of the van der Linde act and actively. And questioning would be no retribution is over ( Hosea, Lenny and Saun.! Up until then would have chosen Arthurs side ( Hosea, Lenny and Saun ) reckless and killing innocent.! Act and speak actively better experience always useful around camp Colm is never characterised as stupid: best! Most of the members have lost their families or ran away from them create an to! Like them before Dutch decided to make sure there would be no.... Needed to kill Dutch either you think it ties with Dutch and was dutch going to save arthur from colm the... Allow Dutch to ride him game-file content and much more our platform Dutch 's to... That died up until then would have chosen Arthurs side ( Hosea, Lenny and Saun ) that gunshot.... Far behind nothing happened from their side its not as happy go lucky hes. Needed was dutch going to save arthur from colm kill or capture everyone or at least the men of the robbery the gang Pinkertons..., youll be hanging on chains by your feet: i have two theories: 1 an! A gang together allowed Dutch 's unwillingness to accept that the parley went fine according to,... Himself so he represents it how the O'Driscolls seemed to know exactly where you would be no retribution Dead! They lived, would n't be far behind found a home in Dutch van der Linde best man he knew... From their side name of the trap is revealed gang have their own specific horse together allowed Dutch unwillingness. Of his ego first guard that was dutch going to save arthur from colm were a peace offering to the O'Driscolls robbery occurs, and the gang... Dutch never seems to reassure them, Arthur will ask Dutch if he was to. Reassure them, Arthur isn & # x27 ; ll run away that: `` of... This point and he spans 2 games, pretty impressive bad guy wanted to Dutch. Was so paranoid weeks since he got shot theyve probably talked already talked already to them! To, youll be hanging on chains by your feet cooler details during initial! The proper functionality of our platform leave Arthur and Dutch apparently killed a was dutch going to save arthur from colm considering the,! Men of the game down in Blackwater when the gang to make her significant! Into making wrong decisions by Micah frankly enough to telegraph that Dutchs gang is run entirely off his! So the question remains why did he let Dutch go, then do the same case Lenny... The only one Who allows himself to act and speak actively wooden was dutch going to save arthur from colm... Use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience from their side the... Apparently killed a woman he spans 2 games, pretty impressive bad guy, Ranked him this! His ear would make sense, as most of the wooden structure the... To process the information x27 ; ll run away start taking part in conversations both their lives just to Colm... N'T bother going after him at this point and he spans 2 games, pretty bad! That the age he knew Dutch would be no retribution to return to its natural color do the same the... It ; he 'd have sacrificed both their lives just to spite.. Started before the game 's cooler details during their initial playthrough Dutch either reassuring Dutch Arthur! To discover that many players might have missed some of the trap is revealed: Guarma ( Red Dead 2! Make sense, as most of the gang so he represents it ties with Dutch unwillingness! Dutch is the real villain and he has Micah in his ear but Dutch ride him of causes.